Online Ordering
You can order online! Browse our menu items and choose what you’d like to order from us.
Ready to order?
Goodness For Ordering
Everything on this menu requires a minimum of 5 days notice to be ordered. Whether a birthday party, business meeting, small family gathering, large catered event, or just because - we are sure you'll find something here to fit your needs.
Thanksgiving Orders
Check one part of your feast off your list - we'll make it for you! Available for pick-up on Thanksgiving Eve or the Friday and Saturday after Thanksgiving!
9" Pies
Made with a classic butter crust and all from scratch fillings.
$17.00
7" Cheesecake
Creamy cheesecakes in a variety of crusts and flavors!
$40.00
1 Dozen Thanksgiving Macarons
A collection of festive macarons
$30.00
6" Pumpkin Tiramisu Cake
Layers of pumpkin cake soaked in coffee and a light coffee mascarpone mousse and powdered with cocoa.
$25.00
Thanksgiving Deluxe Flourish Cupcakes (Dozen)
Deluxe style cupcakes (cake, filling, icing) in an autumn floral style. Pick up to 2 flavors!
$40.00
Gluten Friendly 7" Cheesecake
Creamy cheesecakes in a variety flavors! Made with gluten friendly nut crusts.
$44.00
Gluten Friendly 9" Pies
Made with a gluten friendly butter crust and all from scratch fillings.
$22.00
Rolled Oat Bread
Slightly sweet with oats inside & out. Only available for pick up on Wednesdays and Saturdays.
$5.00 - Unavailable
Gluten Friendly Bread
Only available for pick-up Wednesday through Saturday.
$9.00 - Unavailable
Breads & Sweet Rolls
Sticky Buns
Classic sweet dough rolled up with cinnamon and butter and baked in a brown sugar syrup.
$4.50 - Unavailable
Pecan Sticky Buns
Classic sweet dough rolled up with butter and cinnamon and baked in a brown sugar syrup and pecans.
$5.00 - Unavailable
Cinnamon Rolls
Classic sweet dough rolled up with butter and cinnamon, and topped with sweet cream cheese icing.
$5.00 - Unavailable
Special Sweet Roll
We always have a special sweet roll featured. Some examples are peach bourbon, caramel apple, samoa, gingerbread, and so on. Give us a call, join our email list, or check our social media to find out the current flavor!
$6.00 - Unavailable
Rolled Oat Bread
Slightly sweet with oats inside & out. Only available for pick up on Wednesdays and Saturdays.
$5.00 - Unavailable
White Bread (3 Loaves)
Only available for pick-up Thursday through Saturday.
$15.00 - Unavailable
Gluten Friendly Bread
Only available for pick-up Wednesday through Saturday.
$9.00 - Unavailable
Breakfast Items
Cake Donuts (Half Dozen)
$7.50
Giant Muffins (Half Dozen)
$25.00
Muffins (Half Dozen)
Our cream-cheese filled muffins in a more manageable serving.
$18.00
Eclairs (Half Dozen)
Classic choux pastry with yellow pastry cream filling and chocolate ganache topping.
$15.00
Scones (Half Dozen)
Our signature triangular scones in our favorite flavors.
$18.00
Cream Puffs (Dozen)
Old school choux pastry with yellow pastry cream filling.
$18.00
Desserts & Pastries
These items must be ordered with at least 5 days notice.
Classic Drop Cookies (Half Dozen)
$9.00
Basic Cupcakes (Half Dozen)
A simple cupcake of just cake and icing.
$13.00
Deluxe Cupcakes (Half Dozen)
Includes filling, garnish, and color scheme of choice. See some of our standard flavors below. These all come with a pre-set cake, filling, and icing flavor. If you'd like to customize your own flavors of cupcakes, you may certainly request a variation.
$18.00
Deluxe Flourish Cupcakes (Dozen)
Deluxe style cupcakes (cake, filling, icing) with up to 3 colors of your choice in either a floral or whimsical style. Please indicate colors in the special requests box!
$40.00
Classic Whoopie Pies (Half Dozen)
Our classic PA Dutch whoopie pies are unique in that all our cakes and fillings are made from scratch.
$15.00
Deluxe Whoopie Pies (Half Dozen)
Our signature deluxe whoopie pies take classic whoopie pies to a new level. Flavorful icings sandwiched between circles of cake, then rolled in chocolate and a topping that compliments the flavor.
$18.00
9" Pies
Made with a classic butter crust and all from scratch fillings.
$17.00
7" Cheesecake
Creamy cheesecakes in a variety of crusts and flavors!
$40.00
9" Cheesecake
Creamy cheesecakes in a variety of crusts and flavors! Most flavors available in gluten-friendly versions.
$50.00
3" Tiramisu Square
Layers of genoise sponge soaked in coffee and a light coffee mascarpone mousse and powdered with cocoa.
$5.00
6" Tiramisu Cake
Layers of genoise sponge soaked in coffee and a light coffee mascarpone mousse and powdered with cocoa.
$25.00
Mini Desserts & Pastries
Mini Dessert Variety Package
Choose 3 kinds of our mini desserts, and 2 flavors of each kind. Please indicate your preferred flavors in the special requests section. 1 serving = 3 mini desserts, and you must serve a minimum of 24.
$150.00
Mini Cupcakes (Dozen)
Bite-sized cupcakes.
$20.00
Mini Whoopie Pies (Dozen)
Bite-sized whoopie pies.
$20.00
Tart Bites (Dozen)
Basically the cutest little bite-sized piece of pie you've ever seen.
$22.00
Macarons (Dozen)
Completely customizable in both color and flavor. Colors will reflect the flavor unless otherwise requested. To request a specific color scheme, simply indicate in the "special requests" box.
$30.00
Cake Pops (Dozen)
Cake balls on sticks and dipped in chocolate with sprinkles. Specific color scheme can be requested in the "special requests" box.
$30.00
Cheesecake Bites (Dozen)
Bite sized wedges of cheesecake.
$30.00
Mini Eclairs (Dozen)
Bite-sized choux pastry with cream filling and ganache topping
$24.00
Dessert Shooters (Dozen)
2 oz of mousse based layered desserts
$30.00
Party Trays
Dessert Party Tray
Chef's mix of sweet treats. Smaller tray serves approx. 15 people. Larger tray serves approx. 25 people.
$67.50
Breakfast Party Tray
Chef's mix of breakfast pastries. Smaller tray serves approx. 15 people. Larger tray serves approx. 25 people.
$60.00
Cookie Party Tray
Chef's mix of 4 kinds of classic drop cookies.
$50.00
Gluten Friendly Options
Made without gluten in a kitchen that handles gluten. Cross contamination possible.
Gluten Friendly 9" Pies
Made with a gluten friendly butter crust and all from scratch fillings.
$22.00
Gluten Friendly 7" Cheesecake
Creamy cheesecakes in a variety flavors! Made with gluten friendly nut crusts.
$44.00
Gluten Friendly 9" Cheesecake
Creamy cheesecakes in a variety of crusts and flavors! Most flavors available in gluten-friendly versions.
$55.00
Gluten Friendly Basic Cupcakes (Half Dozen)
A simple cupcake of just cake and icing.
$16.00
Macarons (Dozen)
Completely customizable in both color and flavor. Colors will reflect the flavor unless otherwise requested. To request a specific color scheme, simply indicate in the "special requests" box.
$30.00
Gluten Friendly Cake Donuts (Half Dozen)
$10.00
Gluten Friendly Bread
Only available for pick-up Wednesday through Saturday.
$9.00 - Unavailable
Apple Cider Donuts
Pre-order apple cider donuts for a Friday or Saturday pick-up starting the week of 9/4 through 10/31
Apple Cider Donuts (Dozen)
Made from locally sourced cider from Green's Fruit Farm. Baked cake donut with a lovely blend of warm spices and sugar coated on the outside.
$18.00 - Unavailable
Apple Cider Donut Platter (2 1/2 Dozen)
A white tray filled with apple cider donuts! Perfect for bringing to a gathering.
$40.00 - Unavailable
Apple Cider Donut Platter (5 Dozen)
A white tray filled with apple cider donuts! Perfect for bringing to a gathering.
$75.00 - Unavailable
Afternoon Tea Boxes
To-go afternoon tea boxes, available when we have an afternoon tea! They can be picked up at the bakery the day of our teas or the day following.
Afternoon Tea Box
Please select "Gable House" as the location for pick-up. Only available on select days when we are hosting an afternoon tea.
October 30th - Afternoon Tea Box
All the items from our afternoon tea!
$40.00 - Unavailable
If you're looking to order something with just 2 days notice, select the "Gable House Express" pickup address to unlock the menu of last minute options!
You can also choose "Lewisburg Farmer's Market" if you're looking to pick up at our stand on a Wednesday.